This site is optimised for modern browsers. For the best experience, please use Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge.

Artificial Intelligence and Racial and Ethnic Inequalities in Health and Care Award - Competition 1 Day 2 Panel Meeting Minutes

Contents

Minutes of day 2 of the Artificial Intelligence and Racial and Ethnic Inequalities in Health and Care Award funding panel meeting to discuss applications to Competition 1.

Date and location

Minutes of the Competition 1 Funding Panel Meeting held on Thursday 15 July 2021 via virtual meeting using Zoom

In attendance

Funding Panel Members

  • Professor Peter Bannister (Chair)
  • Dr Naomi Lee (Deputy Chair)
  • Mr Anmol Arora (PPIE representative)
  • Professor Karl Atkin (Chair for application AI_HI200014)
  • Professor Clare Bambra (Attended until 14:20)
  • Professor Michael Barnes
  • Professor Nusrat Husain
  • Professor Gabrielle Finn (Attended for AI_HI200014 only)
  • Dr Bilal Mateen
  • Dr Krish Nirantharakumar
  • Mrs Peju Oshisanya
  • Mr Nanik Pursani (PPIE representative)
  • Professor Nasir Rajpoot

AI PMO Secretariat

  • Dr Ruth Nebauer (Assistant Director)
  • Dr Andrew Barber
  • Dr Silvana Cossins
  • Dr Michelle Edye
  • Dr Aayesha Hassan
  • Miss Deimante Normantaite
  • Dr Raffaella Roncone
  • Mr Edwin Tucker

Operations Team

  • Miss Cordelia Davey
  • Miss Lilian Tomlinson
  • Mrs Samantha Wade

Observers

  • Ms Brhmie Balaram
  • Dr Mai Stafford

Apologies

  • Dr Rohini Mathur
  • Ms Reema Patel
  • Mr Jon Siddall (provided written comments)
  • Ms Jenny Chong (provided written comments)

Applications invited to present at Panel Meeting

AI_HI200007: Understanding AI and racial inequalities for cardiovascular risk assessment
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: Professor Nusrat Husain, Dr Rohini Mathur, Dr Krish Nirantharakumar, Professor Nasir Rajpoot
Final Outcome: Rejected


AI_HI200008: Ethnic differences in performance and perceptions of Artificial Intelligence retinal image analysis systems for the detection of diabetic retinopathy in the NHS Diabetic Eye Screening Programme
Conflicted Funding Panel Member: Mr Anmol Arora
Final Outcome: Funded


AI_HI200004: Ethnic fairness in clinical prediction models used for decision support
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: Professor Nusrat Husain, Dr Bilal Mateen, Dr Krish Nirantharakumar
Final Outcome: Rejected


AI_HI200018: RAINBO: An appRoach for modelling observational dAta to Improve ethNicity coding and Build representative models suitable for ethnic grOups
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: Dr Bilal Mateen, Dr Rohini Mathur
Final Outcome: Rejected


AI_HI200014: STANDING together: STANdards for Data INclusivity and Generalisability
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: Professor Peter Bannister, Dr Naomi Lee, Mr Anmol Arora, Dr Bilal Mateen, Dr Krish Nirantharakumar, Ms Brhmie Balaram (Observer)
Final Outcome: Funded


AI_HI200026: Using machine learning to develop a decision support tool for GPs to address the healthcare needs of Black, Asian and other ethnic minority patients in the community.
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: None
Final Outcome: Rejected


AI_HI200031: Ethnic Bias AI toolkit, score card, benchmark datasets and their application within the NHS
Conflicted Funding Panel Members: Dr Bilal Mateen, Dr Rohini Mathur
Final Outcome: Rejected