This site is optimised for modern browsers. For the best experience, please use Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, or Microsoft Edge.

Beta

This is a new site which is still under development. We welcome your feedback, which will help improve it.

Feedback form

HS&DR Commissioned Prioritisation Committee Public Minutes November 2019

 

Contents

HS&DR Prioritisation Committee Meeting Minutes

Minutes of the November 2019 Meeting

Date Wednesday 20 November 2019
Venue Kensington Suite, Millennium Gloucester Hotel, London

Present members

Peter Brindle Chair
Judith Smith Deputy Chair
Alison Allam
Rebecca Fisher
Carmel Hughes
Sue Jordan
Umesh Kadam
Mona Kanaan
Tiritega Mawaka
Richard McNally
Holly Nelson-Becker
Silviya Nikolova
Adam Noble
Linda Parton
James Rimmer
Carol Rivas
Victoria Tatton
Victoria Tzortziou-Brown
Elizabeth Wade
Adele Webb
Charlotte Williams
Katja Behrendt
Stephen Bradley
Louise Wallace

Apologies

Suzanne Ii
Iestyn Williams
Lois Thomas
Adam Noble
Elizabeth Wade 

Secretariat

Suzy Hopper
Lisa Stockwell
Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
Jo Nurse

In attendance
Nil
Observers
Jo Rycroft-Malone
Vicky Taylor
Clare Gregory

Commissioned Stage 1 proposals: 19/49 Data-enabled trials and studies


The call was introduced by Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
NIHR129773 - Antibiotic Coding and Prescribing Trial. Cluster randomised trial using electronic health records (ACCEPT Trial) (Martin Gulliford)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted

NIHR129827 - Multi-dimensional data analytics and visualisation for population health management: targeting inequalities for exemplar ambulatory care sensitive conditions to improve care outcomes (Umesh Kadam)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: Umesh Kadam, Judith Smith, Rebecca Fisher
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Declined

NIHR130075 - In-silico trials of targeted screening for abdominal aortic aneurysm using linked healthcare data: can the efficiency of the NHS Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Screening Programme be improved whilst maintaining publicly acceptable levels of disease detection in an ethically acceptable manner. (Matthew Bown)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted

NIHR130107 – Adapting Breast Cancer Screening to MAximise Mortality Benefit and Minimise Overdiagnosis harm (Adapt-MAMMO) (Sian Taylor-Phillips)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted

NIHR130581 – Improving antibiotic prescribing in primary care by communication and information support: cluster randomised trial (COMS) (Tjeerd van Staa)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and shortlisted
Decision: Shortlisted

NIHR130439 – eTriage Waiting Lists (Ciaran O’Neill)
Chair: Peter Brindle
Conflict: None
The proposal was discussed by the Committee and declined
Decision: Declined

Summary

19/49 Data-enabled trials Proposal title   

Reference  Proposal Title Outcome
NIHR129773 Antibiotic Coding and Prescribing Trial. Cluster randomised trial using electronic health records (ACCEPT Trial) (Martin Gulliford - King's College London) Shortlist
NIHR129827 Multi-dimensional data analytics and visualisation for population health management: targeting inequalities for exemplar ambulatory care sensitive conditions to improve care outcomes (Umesh Kadam - University of Leicester) Decline
NIHR130075 In-silico trials of targeted screening for abdominal aortic aneurysm using linked healthcare data: can the efficiency of the NHS Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Screening Programme be improved whilst maintaining publicly acceptable levels of disease detection in an ethically acceptable manner. (Matthew Bown - University of Leicester) Shortlist
NIHR130107 Adapting Breast Cancer Screening to MAximise Mortality Benefit and Minimise Overdiagnosis harm (Adapt-MAMMO) (Sian Taylor-Phillips - University of Warwick) Shortlist
NIHR130581 Improving antibiotic prescribing in primary care by communication and information support: cluster randomised trial (COMS) (Tjeerd van Staa - The University of Manchester) Shortlist
NIHR130439  eTriage Waiting Lists (Ciaran O’Neill - The Queen's University of Belfast) Decline