Day One - Wednesday 18 January 2023
Venue
- virtual meeting via Microsoft Teams
Present Members
- Judith Smith (Chair and Deputy Programme Director)
- Alan Smith (Public Committee Member)
- Alexis Foster (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
- Andrew Price
- Annette Boaz
- Debra Bick
- Duncan Stewart
- Elisabeth Atlan (Public Committee Member)
- Greg Irving
- Helen Elliott
- Jenni Burton (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
- Laura Bojke
- Linda Parton (Public Committee Member)
- Lisa Hinton
- Lorna Gibson (Deputy Chair)
- Mona Kanaan
- Nicola Walsh
- Parveen Ali
- Rachel Meacock
- Remi Apata-Omisore (Public Committee Member)
Secretariat
- Tara Lamont
- Suzy Hopper
- Claire Fenton
- Abi Chalk
Apologies
- Kathy Rowan (Programme Director)
- Doreen Joseph
- Fiona Verity
- Muhammad Usman
- Rebecca Harris
- Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
- Dawn Edge, Professor of Mental Health & Inclusivity, University of Manchester (HSDR Inclusion Observer)
Observers
- Joanna Moschandreas, RDS, Senior Trial Statistician, University of Oxford
- Clarissa Giebel, Senior Research Fellow, University of Liverpool (new Committee Member)
- Angela Ruddock (new Public Committee Member)
- Mark Cadman (new Public Committee Member)
- Enya Daynes, Clinical Academic Physiotherapist, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
Quoracy Information
- Voting members: 22 (Quoracy = 66% = 15)
- Voting members present on Day One: 18 (82%)
Stage One Applications
22/102 Supporting the Delivery of a Net Zero Health and Social Care System
NIHR155944 - A multi-centre study to estimate the carbon footprint and patient experience of standard and hypofractionated radiotherapy (Robert Chuter, The Christie NHS Foundation Trust)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Rachel Meacock, Debra Bick
Decision: Shortlist
22/117 HSDR Researcher-led call (Aug 22 - Nov 22)
NIHR156314 - OPTICAL: Optimising Paediatric Transition to Intensive Care for AduLts (Sonya Crowe, University College London)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Kathy Rowan, Lisa Hinton
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156038 - Identifying evidence-based approaches to reduce the link between burnout and unhealthy behaviours among healthcare workers (Anthony Montgomery, Northumbria University)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: None
Decision: Decline
NIHR156061 - The impact of electronic nursing documentation on documentation time, nursing practice, and patient safety: A realist investigation (Rebecca Randell, University of Bradford)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Lorna Gibson, Rachel Meacock
Decision: Decline
NIHR156125 - CARer ADministration of as-needed subcutaneous medication for breakthrough symptoms in people dying at home in the UK: the CARiAD realist evaluation (Marlise Poolman, Bangor University)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Joanna Moschandreas (observer)
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156216 - Understanding and improving endometriosis experiences: a qualitative study into patient and healthcare professionals' experiences of management, diagnosis and treatment (Abigail McNiven, University of Oxford)
Chair: Lorna Gibson
Declared a conflict and left the room: Lisa Hinton, Debra Bick, Joanna Moschandreas (observer)
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR155323 - Increasing engagement and patient experience of cervical screening in primary care: Implementing the left lateral test position (Nicola Walsh, NHS Bristol, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire Integrated Care Board)
Chair: Lorna Gibson
Declared a conflict and left the room: Nicola Walsh
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156423 - Development of an evidence based framework for effective implementation of electronic Medication Administration Recording system (eMAR) within care homes (Linda Birt, NHS Norfolk and Waveney Integrated Care Board)
Chair: Lorna Gibson
Declared a conflict and left the room: Mona Kanaan, Judith Smith
Decision: Decline
NIHR156452 - Getting the bloods to the laboratory: developing behavioural interventions to improve the blood culture pathway for patient safety and antimicrobial stewardship (Carolyn Tarrant, University of Leicester)
Chair: Lorna Gibson
Declared a conflict and left the room: None
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156114 - The Adoption of Artificial Intelligence in Clinical Decision Making in Health and Social Care (Dawn Dowding, The University of Manchester)
Chair: None
Declared a conflict and did not score: Rachel Meacock, Debra Bick
Decision: Decline
22/125 Improving Access and Use of Services for People with Speech, Language, and Communication Needs
NIHR155921 - Improving access to and inclusion in care and rehabilitation for stroke survivors with communication impairments: The development and evaluation of a novel national communication training programme for multidisciplinary stroke rehabilitation staff (Rebecca Palmer, The University of Sheffield)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Mona Kanaan, Alexis Foster, Annette Boaz, Parveen Ali
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156132 - Improving access to mental health services for children and young people with speech, language and communication needs (Emma Pagnamenta, University of Essex)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Laura Bojke, Mona Kanaan, Joanna Moschandreas
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156329 - PLACES: Promoting Local Access to Children’s Early language and communication Support (Lindsay Pennington, University of Newcastle upon Tyne)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: None
Decision: Shortlist
NIHR156640 - Designing and evaluating a multi-stakeholder programme to improve access to mental health services for children and young people with speech, language, and communication needs (Courtenay Norbury, University College London)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Annette Boaz, Mona Kanaan
Decision: Decline
NIHR156435 - Evaluating the delivery of home-based PECS therapy to parents of autistic children with minimal or no verbal communication. (Vicky Slonims, King’s College London)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Rachel Meacock
Decision: Decline
NIHR156523 - Access AAC: a realist evaluation to identify how local commissioning can deliver positive outcomes from augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) (Simon Judge, Barnsley Hospital NHS Foundation Trust)
Chair: None
Declared a conflict and did not score: Alexis Foster
Decision: Decline
Day Two - 19 January 2023
Venue
- virtual meeting via Microsoft Teams
Present Members
- Kathy Rowan (Programme Director)
- Judith Smith (Deputy Programme Director)
- Alan Smith (Public Committee Member)
- Alexis Foster (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
- Andrew Price
- Annette Boaz
- Doreen Joseph
- Duncan Stewart
- Elisabeth Atlan (Public Committee Member)
- Greg Irving
- Helen Elliott
- Jenni Burton (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
- Laura Bojke
- Linda Parton (Public Committee Member)
- Lisa Hinton
- Mona Kanaan
- Nicola Walsh
- Parveen Ali
- Rachel Meacock
- Remi Apata-Omisore (Public Committee Member)
Secretariat
- Tara Lamont
- Suzy Hopper
- Irene Moreno Milan
- Steph Garfield-Birkbeck
- Abi Chalk
Apologies
- Fiona Verity
- Muhammad Usman
- Rebecca Harris
- Lorna Gibson
- Debra Bick
- Dawn Edge, Professor of Mental Health & Inclusivity, University of Manchester (HSDR Inclusion Observer)
Observers
- Petra Makela, Associate Committee Member to Annette Boaz
- Godfred Boahen, Principal Social Worker – Adult Services, London Borough of Hackney (new Committee Member)
- Clarissa Giebel, Senior Research Fellow, University of Liverpool (new Committee Member)
- Graham Martin, Director of Research, THIS Institute (new Committee Member)
- Angela Ruddock, (new Public Committee Member)
- Enya Daynes, Clinical Academic Physiotherapist, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust (Committee Member Development Scheme (CMDS) Participant)
Quoracy Information
- Voting members: 22 (Quoracy = 66% = 15)
- Voting members present on Day Two: 18 (82%)
Stage One Applications
22/116 NICE Rolling Call
NIHR156488 - Improving kidney failure risk calculations in ethnically diverse populations (Mariam Molokhia, King's College London)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Judith Smith, Graham Martin, Annette Boaz
Decision: Shortlist
22/103 Delivering a Sustainable Health and Care System
NIHR156635 - Comparing the impact of care closer to home initiatives on NHS and social care and how these are incorporated in service planning and commissioning (Stephen Peckham, University of Kent)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Rachel Meacock
Decision: Decline
NIHR156626 - Delivering high quality low carbon care across the NHS; building a methodological approach for decarbonising clinical care pathways (Jenny Shand, UCL Partners)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Judith Smith
Decision: Decline
NIHR155444 - Freight as a Service for the NHS (FaaS NHS) (Janet Dickinson, Bournemouth University)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Judith Smith
Decision: Shortlist
Stage Two Applications
22/46 NICE Rolling Call
NIHR154205 - Pragmatic Evaluation of Effectiveness and Acceptability of the Bristol Medication Review Toolkit (BRISMED) (Deborah McCahon, University of Bristol)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Nicki Walsh
Decision: Fund with changes
22/11 Implementing the Mental Capacity Act in Practice
NIHR154668 - Use of the Mental Capacity Act 2005 with people experiencing multiple exclusion homelessness in England (Jill Manthorpe, King’s College London)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Annette Boaz, Clarissa Giebel
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR152800 - Evaluating staff training and the implementation of the Mental Capacity Act in care homes for older adults (Alys Griffiths, University of Liverpool)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Greg Irving, Clarissa Giebel
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR153264 - High-quality mental capacity assessments for hEalthcare decisions: improving Leadership, assessment Procedures, and service user Support (HELPS) (Domenico Giacco, University of Warwick)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Judith Smith, Greg Irving, Debra Bick, Laura Bojke, Mona Kanaan
Decision: Fund with changes
22/10 Adult Social Care Needs Assessment
NIHR154077 - Assessing care needs of older adults and their carers (ASSESS) (Stacey Rand, University of Kent)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Laura Bojke, Jenni Burton, Alan Smith, Annette Boaz, Alexis Foster, Petra Makela (observer), Clarissa Giebel (observer), Mona Kanaan
Decision: Not Fund
22/47 Researcher-led
NIHR153960 - Developing and evaluating a peer-based approach to updating living Evidence and Gap Maps for health and social care (Sian de Bell, University of Exeter)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: None
Decision: Not Fund
NIHR153121 - Evaluating the impact of artificial intelligence triage in online consultations to reduce delays in urgent and emergency primary care (Benjamin Brown, The University of Manchester)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Rachel Meacock, Angela Ruddock (observer)
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR153603 - Service configurations for psychosis – what works for whom in what combinations and contexts and why? A realist evidence synthesis (Sue Holttum, Canterbury Christ Church University)
Chair: Judith Smith
Declared a conflict and left the room: Doreen Joseph, Laura Bojke, Rachel Meacock, Alexis Foster, Parveen Ali
Decision: Fund with changes
NIHR152830 - SafeTy, clinical, system effects and costs of AmbuLances queuing with deLayed patient handovers at Emergency Departments (STALLED) (Helen Snooks, Swansea University)
Chair: Kathy Rowan
Declared a conflict and left the room: Alexis Foster, Judith Smith
Decision: Not Fund