Published: 13 August 2020
Breast screening women aged 40-49 reduces breast cancer mortality with minimal increased overdiagnosis, finds NIHR-funded research that looked at data from 160,000 women.
The UK, along with many other countries, has a breast cancer screening programme offering mammography to women aged 50–70 years every three years. However, uncertainty currently exists over whether to start screening at a younger age, including whether it might lead to overdiagnosis of breast cancer.
Between 1990 and 1997, the UK Breast Screening Age Trial randomised more than 160,000 UK women aged 39-41 to receive either annual mammography, or the usual NHS breast screening which commences at age 50. The primary outcome was mortality from breast cancers diagnosed prior to the first NHS breast screen.
New analysis, led by Queen Mary University of London is now published in The Lancet Oncology. It presents the 23-year follow-up results of the trial and finds that screening women aged 40-49 led to a substantial and significant 25 per cent reduction in breast cancer mortality in the first ten years. The total years of life saved from breast cancer in the intervention group was estimated as 620, corresponding to 11.5 years saved per 1,000 women invited to earlier screening.
The results also suggest at worst modest overdiagnosis in this age group, and that any overdiagnosed cancers would otherwise be diagnosed at NHS screening from 50 years of age. Therefore, screening in the age group of 40–49 years does not appear to add to overdiagnosed cases from screening at age 50 years and older.
Lead researcher Professor Stephen Duffy from Queen Mary University of London, said: “This is a very long term follow-up of a study which confirms that screening in women under 50 can save lives. The benefit is seen mostly in the first ten years, but the reduction in mortality persists in the long term at about one life saved per thousand women screened.
“We now screen more thoroughly and with better equipment than in the 1990’s when most of the screening in this trial took place, so the benefits may be greater than we’ve seen in this study.”
The researchers say that more research is needed to clarify whether progress in early detection technology and treatment of breast cancer might modify the screening-related reduction in mortality in the 40-49 age group. They also did not consider the cost-effectiveness of lowering the screening age.
The study was funded by NIHR’s Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Programme, and included experts from King’s College London, University of Nottingham, University of Dundee and Tel Aviv University.
More information about the study is available on the NIHR’s Funding & Awards website.